My RPG

A rules-light tabletop RPG by Ron Helwig

Opportunity Attacks Rationale

This archive page records why MyRPG has no automatic attacks of opportunity, and why the opt-in reaction attacks look the way they do.

The Question

In D&D, leaving an enemy’s reach provokes an attack automatically. Fictionally that is an opportunity: the enemy sees an opening and takes it. That sounds like a natural fit for MyRPG’s scene clock, which is built for exactly that kind of “one special read of this situation” (see Time & Scenes).

Why Scene Is the Wrong Clock

  • Openings in a fight are many, not one. A real duelist punishes every careless step, not just the first.
  • A once per scene opportunity attack would fire once and then vanish, which feels arbitrary and makes the second retreat strangely safe.
  • Removing the limit entirely brings back what we wanted to avoid: every table tracking who threatens whom on every move.

What MyRPG Does Instead

  • No automatic attacks of opportunity. Moving away from an enemy is safe unless that enemy has a Feature or spell that opts in (see Reactions).
  • Opt-in reaction attacks are gated by the per-round Reaction and Action Load, not by scene. Load is the natural throttle: every reaction costs headroom you would otherwise spend on your own turn, so “sticky” characters can punish openings repeatedly, at a real price.
  • That is why Features like Opening Strike (Aegis, Weapon Master), Forced Exposure (Skirmish), and Zone Denial (Aegis) exist: the fiction of seizing an opening belongs to characters who have trained for it, not to every creature by default.

Summary

Opportunity attacks are opportunity fiction, but they happen too often for a scene gate. MyRPG keeps movement simple by default and lets reactions plus Action Load carry the “punish the opening” fantasy for those who choose it.